Choosing the Best Candidate… or Finding New Ones

Hiring a new candidate for your company can be a complex situation. After posting the position, choosing the short list of interview candidates and performing interview rounds, you are now faced with a difficult challenge – choosing the best fit candidate for your business.  However, it is surprising how much interviewers’ impressions can change once they all have an opportunity to carefully discuss and consider all of the candidates. Be sure your approach to selecting the best candidate is a comprehensive and consistent approach.

Soon after interviews are completed, interviewers together select the best candidate.

Within one or at most two weeks after all interviews have been completed, convene the interviewers. Consider a consistent method to select the best candidate from among the interviewers. For example, mention the name of a candidate, and allow 15 minutes total for all interviewers to share their impressions of that candidate. Also share results of any comments from references and/or background checks. Repeat the process for each candidate. After all candidates have been discussed, then list the candidates again, this time having interviewers vote for the best candidate from the list.

If there does not seem to be suitable candidate, then consider the following:

  1. Are the job requirements too stringent or an odd mix? For example, the job might require someone with strong technical skills and also someone with strong clerical skills. Those two types of skills are sometimes unusual to expect to mix together.
  2. Reconfigure the job so that the nature of the required skills and training are somewhat similar and so that the overall nature of the job becomes more common.
  3. Hire the candidate who most closely matched the requirements of the job and then plan for dedicated training to bring that person’s skills up to needed levels.
  4. Re-advertise the position.
  5. Get advice from a human resources professional. At this point, your need for their advice is probably quite specific, so they might provide services on a pro bono basis.
  6. Hire a consultant for the position on a short-term basis, but only as a last resort as this may be quite expensive.

How to Retain Employees During Times of Change

Retaining talented employees is one of the topmost priorities of employers today. Without the right people with the right skills, your business can’t consistently fulfill your customer’s needs. The challenge is not only to attract the best talent but also to retain them.

Rising opportunities for career development, lifestyle decisions, job mobility, unbalanced work life, poor mentoring and stress are some factors which influence and individual’s decision to continue or quite. Among other things, a retention strategy demands respecting employees’ concerns right from their entry into the organization till their retirement. It encompasses the organization’s ability to provide the best of work climates.

What Troubles Employees?

Employees expect from their employers to:

  • Provide induction
  • Create a good work environment
  • Motivate them to work
  • Train them
  • Provide a suitable compensation package
  • Implement reward strategies
  • Counsel them
  • Hold affable exit interviews

An appropriate HR strategy alone can satisfy employee expectations.

Where are companies going wrong in these times of change?

Too many companies approach the retention of key employees during disruptive periods of organizational change by throwing financial incentives at senior executives, star performers, or other “rainmakers”. The money is rarely well spent!

There is a better and less costly approach to employee retention—and one that will serve companies well as they merge, restructure, and reorganize to seize strategic opportunities as the economy picks up. It starts with identifying all key players, but targeting only those who are most critical and most at risk of leaving. These people are then offered a mix of financial and nonfinancial incentives tailored to their aspirations and concerns.

Three suggestions for Retaining Employees

  • HR and line managers need to work together during times of major organizational change to identify people whose retention is critical. Yet too often companies simply round up the usual suspects—high-potential employees and senior executives in roles that are critical for business success. The “hidden gems” might be found anywhere in the company: a Business Development manager who is nearing his retirement age and is no longer on the company’s list of’ high potentials”. Even if the employees’ performance and career potential are unexceptional, their institutional knowledge, direct relationships, or technical expertise can make their retention critical.
  • One-size-fits-all retention packages are usually unsuccessful in persuading a diverse group of key employees to stay. Instead, companies should tailor retention approaches to the mind-sets and motivations of specific employees.
  • Financial incentives play an important role in retention—but money alone won’t do the trick. Praise from one’s manager, attention from leaders, frequent promotions, opportunities to lead projects, and chances to join fast-track management programs are often more effective than cash. Leadership opportunities are a powerful incentive in any sector.

When financial incentives are required, it is important to design them appropriately and use them in a targeted way.

Closing Thoughts

Targeting retention measures at the right people using a tailored mix of financial and nonfinancial incentives is crucial for managing organizational transitions that achieve long-term business success; it’s also likely to save money.

Seizing Competitor HR Assets

SPECIAL GUEST BLOG By David Parkinson, Human Resources Mentor, Mentors.ie

Leveraging Industry Failure For a Strong Internal Team

One of the sad truths in today's economy is that a large number of industries aren't going to weather the storm.

When you see or hear that a major competitor has left the marketplace, your initial reaction may be one of elation. More consumers will be up for grabs and you have a strong chance of converting them to your product or service.

Often unconsidered is the fact that the internal knowledgebase of your competitors is also on the auction block. With unemployment rates high, many well qualified people are seeking work, creating a "buyers market" for fantastic talent. The employees of your former competitor are aware of the difficulties of job seeking and are very likely to view any overtures on your behalf positively. 

 Leveraging HR Assets

The first step to knowing how to best use this advantage is knowing what you need. 

Carefully assess the human resources that you have available to you in your current organization and identify key points that you feel should be strengthened for better success in the future. 

Consider whether you should "hire up" (replacing current employees with better qualified talent for the same price) or "muscle up" (adding new talent to an already strong team for broader depth).

Broadcasting Opportunity

In a time when media is full of financial doom and gloom, it's important to demonstrate (both for prospective employees and investors) that you're still going strong. 

Are you suddenly the only company in your industry? Perhaps you should send a press release announcing that fact. Has your company maintained profitability? A video broadcast on your homepage should drawn attention to this. Is your employee turnover rate negligable despite the downturn? Mention this is a job posting for your ideal candidate.

Take a few minutes to post positions for your ideal candidates on the internet. For minimal cost, it's worth putting the message out that you're seeking to hire great talent… and drawing competitor talent towards you. Inform your HR staff to specifically look for candidates that list your former competitor on their resumes.

Turning Enemies Into Friends

When you've been contacted by a former competitor's employee, the work is just beginning. In a competitive field, your former-competitors-employee-now-your-prospective-star-talent must be "turned" by more than simply a new name on the paycheck. 

Ask your new prospect what they liked and disliked about thier last employer. Ask them what they felt were the challenges that the previous employer couldn't overcome (and ultimately lead to business failure). Ask them what they would have done differently, and what internal obstacles they faced that prevented them from doing those things.

Finally, your challenge is to convince the new prospective employee that your company was the better employer choice all along. Illustrate your successes. Sell your culture. Make it a better fit, and you will be gaining not only valuable talent but also a life-long proponent for your company's success.  

Whether you're recruiting for former competitor employees or you're simply recruiting for a stronger internal team, Mentor.ie can provide you with guidance and assistance with your recruitment strategy in today's marketplace, to help you reap rewards not only today but for years to come.

How to Hire the New Employee

With back to school season now underway, it seems an appropriate time for a primer on the best process for hiring a new employee.  You send a strong message to the candidate in the way that you provide the job offer to them. It is best to be both business-like and personal in your approach.

1. Provide a written job offer to the most qualified candidate.

The letter should come from the person who will be supervising the new employee. In the letter:

  1. Convey that you are pleased to offer the job to the candidate.
  2. Specify the exact amount of compensation offered to him/her.
  3. Specify the benefits offered to him/her.
  4. Specify the date on which to start the job.
  5. Include a signature line that the candidate can sign.
  6. Ask him/her to sign a copy of the offer letter and return it to you by a certain date. Give them at least one week to consider the job offer.
  7. Mention if there is a probationary period and the length of the period.
  8. Mention who he/she can contact if there are any questions.
  9. Attach a copy of the job description to be sure that the offer is associated with the correct job.

2. If everyone declines the job offer, then consider the following:

  1. Ask the best candidates why they declined the offer. Usually, you will hear the same concerns, for example, the pay is too low, the benefits incomplete, the organization seems confused about what it wants from the role, or the interview process seemed hostile or contentious.
  2. Reconvene the interviewers and consider what you heard from the candidates. Recognize what went wrong and correct the problem. Contact your favorite candidate, admit the mistake and what you did to correct it, and why you would like to make an offer to him/her again.
  3. Go to the second choice. Sometimes the process of re-examining the candidates can bring a second-choice candidate to the front.
  4. Re-advertise the position.

3. Otherwise, start a personnel file for the new employee.

The personnel file with contain all of the job-related information and material, for example, the employee’s resume, job description, job offer, signed offer letter, completed tax withholding forms, signed forms for benefits, etc.

4. Do not forget to send letters to the candidates who did not get the job.

They deserve a sincere letter from you that thanks them for their consideration and for interviewing for the job. Clearly explain that another candidate most closely matched the qualifications specified in the job description. If you plan to retain their job applications, then mention that to them so they are aware that they still might be considered for other jobs that arise in the organization.

© 2010 Mentors.ie All rights reserved.

Powered by Wordpress